Old Fashioned Caramels

$0.80

Available Now!

Trust
Icon

Trust
Icon

Our own recipe since 1939. These creamy caramels are buttery soft, "like Grandma used to make". We use only the highest quality cream, butter, and sugar to create a smooth and creamy melt-in-your-mouth taste experience.

Customer Reviews

Based on 16 reviews
100%
(16)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
B
Beth B
Aimee and Tom are amazing and their candy is as well.

The candy is awesome, the owners are awesome, the help is awesome. Why bother going anywhere else? I'll be placing my holiday order soon!

L
LJo
Wonderful!

These caramels are buttery and delicious!

E
Emily Ladewig
Caramel Bliss

Hands down best caramel! You can’t have just one. Currently have a bag in my kitchen.

L
Linda Russell
Scrumptious

Love the caramels! My staff counts on Lillie Mae caramels for holidays. We all love them!

A
Amy McGraw
The best caramel!

Lillie Mae makes the best caramel, hands down. Homemade and delicious, for decades!