Old Fashioned Fudge

Our fresh cream and butter fudge is out of this world. Super creamy and made in delicious combinations with our candies and caramels. You’ll love this creamy old-fashioned fudge!!!

12 products

Sort

Fudge Sale Buy a Pound Get a Half Pound Free- Homemade Variety Gift Pack

$19.00

Peanut Butter Cup Fudge

from $4.75

Cookies and Cream Fudge made with Oreos

from $4.75

Chocolate Walnut Fudge - Main Street Mudd on the Rocks

from $4.75

Our creamy amaretto fudge is swirled with our chocolate fudge

Mary Kathleen's Amazing Amaretto

from $4.75

Nana Becky's Butter Pecan Fudge

from $4.75

Ethel Mae's Maple Nut

from $4.75

Fudge Lovers Pack - 6 Piece Chocolate or Variety Gift Pack

$28.50

TorTush (Turtle) Fudge - Chocolate fudge with a gooey caramel nut center and white chocolate/ caramel topping

from $4.75

Chocolate Oreo Cookie Fudge

from $4.75

Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel Fudge

from $4.75

Caramel Chocolate Peanut Fudge (Like a Snickers)

from $4.75

Easy ordering for your group

Traditional

This is the same as it was when I was a kid. They make the best Caramels. I haven't even mentioned th chocolates......oh my. Great ice cream selection. You can't miss this place if you're in Marshalltown, iowa. Quaint shop.

Mother’s Day box

It was perfect! Great way to send my mom a local gift!

Like the chocolate but....

Your products are very good. However I didn't care for the random mix of centers. I understand as a fundraiser, that is 'easiest' for packaging several orders. But I would like to see ordering options such as: 'mystery' (what we received), cream centers, nuts, etc,
The caramels are delicious. And yes, the candies are good! But just passing on an observation/suggestion.

Loved the May Baskets!

I thought they were really cute. I was in the group that made the baskets before the current group. They are a lot of work but really fun. You did a nice job of filling them for a reasonable price. My ladies I gave the to enjoyed getting them. One husband wanted to kiss me!! I would buy them again.

Great Chocolate

I have problems eating caramels, but yours are so soft that I could eat a lot more of them than I should. A friendly company that makes ordering easy.
Val

Old Fashioned Fudge

Easy ordering for your group

Let customers speak for us

Lillie Mae Chocolate - Creating Joy since 1939

Let customers speak for us